Being Holy 2.0 – Reclaiming Holiness for Our Time

What does it mean to become holy today? And do we still believe that God's grace can truly transform the human person? In his engagement with Fr. Andreas Batlogg SJ's book Being Holy 2.0, Fr. George Elsbett LC welcomes the author's effort to free holiness from the pressures of perfectionism and spiritual self-improvement. At the same time, he raises a crucial question: In bringing the saints down from their pedestals, do we risk losing sight of the extraordinary greatness of our Christian calling? A personal and theological dialogue about the power of grace, human freedom, the significance of the sacraments, and the hope that genuine transformation is possible.

von | 1. Oktober 2026

Publishing this book was a bold venture for a man moving up and down the German speaking ecclesial and theological landscape. Proposing holiness as the ideal of a life well lived will not meet with universal applause. Yet that is precisely what the new book by Fr. Andreas Batlogg, SJ, seeks to do: Being Holy 2.0.

Background

Before speaking with the author, I had not yet recognized this intention. I was, rather, agitated because I felt unfairly criticized. I would have liked nothing more than to write a response immediately. But I could hardly do that without even having read the book itself. Besides, it would have been hypocritical. I want to speak about an authentic Christian lifestyle, yet I cannot even muster the sincerity to speak with the person concerned. Especially when that person lives not on the other side of the world, or in Hamburg or Munich, but a mere ten-minute walk from my own front door. What had happened?

In August, P. Andreas Batlogg, SJ, published his book Heilig sein 2.0 (Being Holy 2.0 ). In September, katholisch.at published a review. I was not thrilled by it. Above all, because it presented my blog post of May 5, 2018, “I Want to Become Holy. Really. What About You?” and our Center’s tagline—“Forming apostles to transform the world”—as negative examples. Since Fr. Batlogg is no ordinary figure—he was responsible for the Karl Rahner Archive in Munich for many years and served as editor-in-chief of the Jesuit journal „Stimmen der Zeit„—I wanted to write a clarification for our community. But before doing so, I wanted to inform myself more thoroughly: not just about what an online portal said about the book, but about what the book itself actually said. So I worked my way through its individual chapters.

I also began reading another of the author’s books, one of his two biographies of Pope Francis, The Evangelical Pope. Finally, I asked him for a conversation. And I am grateful I did. I am somewhat embarrassed to admit that I almost published my clarification without first speaking to the author. Once again, I was reminded: we must learn to speak with one another, not against one another. Especially within the Church.

Fr. Batlogg explained to me that he had understood the title of my blog post positively—something katholisch.at had failed to grasp in its review of his book. A negative intention would have surprised me, too, since the question in the title comes—with a slight adaptation—from a document by John Paul II (Novo millennio ineunte, no. 31), while our tagline is an adaptation of a quotation from Pope Francis that Fr. Batlogg himself quotes in one of his two biographies of Francis (The Evangelical Pope): “Authentic faith always involves a profound desire to change the world.” (Homily at the Jesuit Church of Il Gesù in Rome, January 3, 2014.) My first impression of the book was this: a great deal is deconstructed, and very little constructed. So holiness is not any of these things. What, then, is it? Or should we simply remove the word from our vocabulary as quickly as possible? But our deeply enriching, personal conversation helped me better understand the framing. I now believe that the author’s concern is quite different—indeed, I would call it courageous. He wants to make a case for holiness in a challenging ecclesial context. What follows is my attempt to engage with the contents of the book and, through them, with the subject of holiness.

Taking the Saints Down from Their Pedestals

Holiness: what it is and how one goes about it. That, then, is what Fr. Batlogg’s book Being Holy 2.0 is about. At the same time, the title suggests that version 1.0 is no longer helpful—or at least needs revising—when we ask how Christian living can succeed today.

Relatively early in the book, Fr. Batlogg recounts an initiative by the Benedictine Martin Werlen at the Priory of St. Gerold in Austria. Major renovations had become necessary because of fire-safety regulations. For practical reasons, statues of saints had to be taken down from their pedestals. Prior Werlen made a virtue of necessity by placing the statues amid everyday surroundings. “Taking the saints down from their pedestals” became an initiative of a special kind. The metaphor could hardly be clearer. Idealizing hagiographies, along with unhealthy ideas about what holiness actually is, have done more to damage than to help the witness of many saints. Saints were elevated onto a spiritual pedestal where they do not belong. A way of life so otherworldly was attributed to them that they became unapproachable. Their human side was forgotten. People neglected to tell of their rough edges, played them down, or suppressed them altogether. Their weaknesses, their doubts, their struggles were not allowed to exist; consequently, they were portrayed as though those things had never existed.

For Fr. Batlogg, behind this distortion lies a conception of holiness that misses the very essence of what is at stake. This distorted picture understands holiness primarily in terms of what might be called a “spirituality of achievement.” According to this view, through personal effort and self-optimization, a person can gradually rise out of the sinful everyday existence of “ordinary” believers and attain ever-higher degrees of virtue. A “heroic degree of virtue” would then elevate that person to sainthood.

Today, catechumens (candidates for baptism) “often want to be handed instructions for how Christianity works, a to-do list, so to speak, that I have to work through in order to reach the goal” (p. 164). The thesis of Being Holy 2.0 is that there is no instruction manual for becoming holy. “Christianity is Jesus, the Christ, a person by whom we orient ourselves, not primarily a system of dogma and morality” (p. 164). The point is to live in relationship with him—indeed, to live out of that relationship. And since every relationship is unique and can never be fully accessible to an outsider, a standardized, stage-by-stage conception of holiness—predetermined stages identical for everyone, which each individual simply has to pass through to become holy—is absurd.

I find much to appreciate in everything said so far. For me, one of the most beautiful passages is a quotation from Johannes Bours: “The saint of tomorrow is a person who knows himself to be so loved by God, who knows himself to be looked upon so lovingly by God in Jesus Christ, that he becomes completely free. He can let go; he no longer needs to cling to things; he no longer needs guarantees; he no longer needs to join in all the frantic running about that everyone around him is doing. He is free. He has everything in this: I am loved by God … He lives differently … He can let go, give, share, distribute, because he is infinitely rich: looked upon by God in Jesus Christ! That is why the saints of today and tomorrow radiate nothing gloomy, but rather a joy that throws the world’s usual patterns into disarray. The saints of today and tomorrow are servants of our joy!” (pp. 172–173)

The Danger of a Spirituality of Achievement

Thankfully, Fr. Batlogg does not understand holiness as perfectionism. For perfectionism feeds on egoism and pride. One follows certain rules in order to become holy. But without a “Thou,” the source of motivation for this journey falls back upon the self. “I want to become holy.” Ultimately, one does this not out of love but to live up to one’s own expectations of oneself. “I want to become holy” must always arise as a response to God’s love, not as an ego project.

In practice, this egoism often manifests itself as frustration with oneself when one has failed to remain faithful to one’s self-imposed ideal, or has simply fallen short of it. One is sorry not because one has hurt God or another person, but because one is not as perfect as one wanted to be. At the beginning of Mass, the Catholic act of worship, stands the confession of sins. I confess that I am a sinner. The self-righteous person finds this difficult.

What makes this form of pride so dangerous is that it disguises itself as humility: “I am so terrible; I have failed again.” Often this reaction has very little to do with true humility. The proud person finds it difficult to acknowledge having faults, being inadequate, being a sinner. One acts as though one were sorry. Except that what one regrets is not the fact of having inflicted wounds on another person, but one’s own weakness. One ends up in self-pity, unable to accept one’s own inadequacy, wishing one could erase the mistake from one’s personal history. But again: not because the reason lies in having wounded a “Thou,” but because one finds one’s own inadequacy abhorrent. The idealized image of one’s own self has been scratched by the mistake or sin. And that is precisely what one cannot bear. An ideal can inspire, but it can also crush. This is one of Fr. Batlogg’s insights that deserves even more attention. We repeatedly hear of children from supposedly especially religious homes who abandon their faith—particularly where the impression is that everything revolved around maintaining an ideal of perfection, around observing rules for the sake of the rules themselves. But being a Christian is a matter of relationship. It is not a self-centered pursuit of perfection through compliance with behavioral rules. There will be more to say on this subject later.

Distorted Hagiographies, Instrumentalization, Abuse

I also find other aspects of the book very valuable.

One is the observation that devotion to the saints can acquire a momentum of its own, leading people to attribute behavior and ways of living to a saint that bear little or no relation to the historical facts.

Then there is the danger of instrumentalization, especially in the case of saints who died young. The author asks, for example, whether St. Carlo Acutis has fallen victim to this in some places. A saint of the new media was convenient—and one was found. People want to promote a particular kind of Eucharistic devotion and have found a brilliant representative for it. With all due respect and appreciation, and without questioning the holiness of this particular saint himself, that is a legitimate concern. It becomes more pressing when the saint is presented in an embellished way. Did St. Mother Teresa not become much more approachable to us after we learned of her decades of interior darkness, her nights of faith? Does St. Teresa of Ávila not become more sympathetic once we discover that her character was not always easy? Things become difficult when, through emphasizing some aspects and omitting others, one cannot quite shake the impression that a saint is being instrumentalized.

Another aspect touched upon in the book is the issue of power structures and abuse. It is no secret that in the past priests in particular were often placed, if not on a pedestal, then certainly on an elevated platform: “Reverend.” Perhaps he is not holy, but certainly closer to what is holy, and holier than the rest of the population. This often leaves the priest isolated—after all, he stands alone on his pedestal—which in turn brings a whole series of other problems. Yes, far more distinctions are needed here; this is a complex problem. Reducing a situation to a single cause is often problematic. At the same time, it would be reductive not to acknowledge that this was one of the reasons why clerical abusers were able to commit their crimes more easily: they were neither suspected nor questioned. On a personal note, I was pleased to see certain saints mentioned in the book. One is Óscar Romero, even if he appears only briefly. I used to have an ambivalent relationship with him. Especially in recent years, however, I have come to appreciate his life, his messages, and his homilies deeply—because I read not only what others said about him, but his own writings. I was particularly pleased by the somewhat longer treatment of the Jesuit Alfred Delp. His writings fascinate me. Only last year I made a pilgrimage to Munich—to the last place where he ministered, where the Gestapo arrested him on July 28, 1944.

Going Too Far? The Greatness of the Redeemed Human Person

I do wonder, however, whether in all the effort to avoid a spirituality of achievement and self-optimization, the pendulum has not swung beyond a healthy balance. Yes, saints are not demigods. Elevating them into spheres where the ideal remains unattainable does not help.

And yet: Would it not do us good, here and there, to put the saints we have taken down back onto their pedestals? Not as a distorted, utopian, idealized picture of what Christian living must be. But rather to draw people’s attention to the fact that saints actually exist. That there are still people up there on those pedestals, visibly showing us that the measure of the human person is eternity, and that genuine transformation “from glory to glory, by the Spirit of the Lord” (2 Cor 3:18) is a real possibility for human beings. Indeed, it is their true vocation through redemption in Jesus Christ.

Role models. Where can we still find them? Has the deconstruction of our ideals not also contributed to our no longer believing in the greatness of the human person? Drawing on Paul Ricœur, John Paul II spoke of the “masters of suspicion”: Nietzsche, Marx, Freud. They advanced the suspicion that the human heart is ultimately incapable of good. The Gospel sets against this the truth of redemption: “Man cannot stop at putting the human heart into a state of continual and irrevocable suspicion on account of the manifestations of the lust of the flesh and libido, which a psychoanalyst, among others, points out through the analysis of the subconscious. Redemption is a truth, a reality, in whose name man must feel called—and called effectively.” (John Paul II, General Audience, October 29, 1980, no. 4; translated by the author from the Italian.)

The Heart under Suspicion and the Multiplication of Rules and Controls

If this were not so, a great many strict rules would be needed to keep people under control. Throughout Church history, this way of thinking has repeatedly wreaked havoc.

My own religious congregation could sing a song about it—a lament. Before our very lengthy process of purification and healing, our constitutions contained more than 800 numbered provisions. Because members of the congregation were not trusted to apply general principles to concrete circumstances themselves, an attempt was made to do it for them through a vast number of rules. But this carries the danger of producing immature people who obey rules like puppets, for the sake of the rules themselves, instead of seeking to understand the “why” behind them and then deciding for themselves. If a mother tells her child not to eat chocolate during Lent, and answers the child’s question “Why?” with “Because it’s Lent,” she has not actually given the child a reason. It accords with human dignity to recognize precisely that reason and orient one’s actions accordingly.

I find Fr. Batlogg’s contribution valuable in precisely this respect as well. I notice that young adults of Generation Z often want to be told what to do. I deliberately try to counteract that tendency. Handing over responsibility, or surrendering it to an external rulebook or a guru, is the exact opposite of what we hope for from a “saint.”

Denying human beings their greatness and their actual capacities leads not only to an unhealthy proliferation of rules in public life, but also contributes to the formation of autocratic systems and narcissistic leaders. Where virtues are replaced by rules, political systems tend to become authoritarian in order to enforce compliance with those rules. For this reason too, it seems to me that we would benefit from putting saints back on their pedestals, rather than only taking them down. At the same time, I work with so many young people who doubt themselves, their worth, their abilities; who constantly question themselves; who look toward the future with anxiety, including their own future. The point is not to send them racing back into a frantic pursuit of achievement and self-optimization—not even one dressed up in religious clothing. Christians know the danger of theories of self-redemption: that they lead to frustration and burnout … and to still greater self-doubt and discouragement. Emphasizing this is a great merit of Being Holy 2.0. And yet. It seems to me that the urgent need of our time is not only to counteract an achievement-oriented society. It is also, and especially, to place before the younger generations—and not only them—the greatness of the human person redeemed in Jesus Christ. If we want to give people hope that human life can truly flourish, we must not forget this.

A Unity in Tension: Freedom and Grace

Hence the question: Should we not preserve here, as so often in Catholic thought, what Guardini calls a “unity in tension”—or what Andy Stanley (the American pastor known, among other things, for his leadership podcast) would call “correlative values”? If I devote myself only to my family, I lose my work. If I devote myself only to my work, I lose my family. This is not a problem I want to solve, but a tension I want to maintain and manage well … knowing that this is no easy undertaking.

Jesus is God. But he is also man. Not some mixture, somehow half man and half God, but truly God and truly man. He is King—but a King who washes feet. He is Lion and yet Lamb. He is Lord (Kyrios), and yet also Friend. His free human will is not erased by the divine. Rather, this human will becomes perfectly human precisely through its agreement with the divine will. And what is true of Jesus Christ by nature becomes true of us through grace and participation.

Yes. Everything is grace. But we are allowed to participate. Grace does not nullify our free cooperation; it makes that cooperation possible and sustains it. A saying attributed to Ignatius tells us to pray as though everything depended on God, and act as though everything depended on you. Both are true. These very paradoxes run through the entire Christian undertaking. Freedom and grace. Tradition and Scripture. Charism and institution. Faith and reason. Mercy and justice. Following the way of the Cross and the joy of the Resurrection. Both feet firmly planted on the ground of reality, yet knowing that our homeland is in heaven. Contemplation and action. Yes, our sanctification is God’s work, but it also requires human cooperation; the human person is permitted to cooperate. And not only that: through the power of the Holy Spirit, a horizon of possibilities opens before us that exceeds our boldest dreams, for: “Now to him who is able to accomplish infinitely more than all we ask or imagine, according to the power at work within us, to him be glory …” (Eph 3:20–21). In his critique, Fr. Batlogg speaks of what I earlier called a spirituality of achievement. He says that it causes us to miss the heart of the matter. But despite all the paraphrases and distinctions, it seems to me that what this heart of the matter actually is remains diffuse. And I wonder whether the reason has to do with the understanding of the sacraments.

A Sacramental Understanding and Real Transformation

At the beginning of the book, the concept of holiness is explored in greater depth. This also leads Fr. Batlogg to discuss holy places and, more generally, whether it makes sense to speak of a greater concentration of the presence of the Holy in one place, or whether that presence is exactly the same everywhere.

In this context the Eucharist is discussed, although he lets the theologian Gottfried Bachl speak for him. The medieval metaphysical understanding, with its Aristotelian structure, is said to be outdated. Signs such as “God is here” (on an altar cloth before the Blessed Sacrament in a church, for example) are said to be misleading. God is no more present in the Eucharist in the tabernacle or the monstrance than elsewhere, since God is everywhere. What is specific to the Eucharist concerns the humanity of Jesus, not his divinity. “The heavens declare the glory of God; the firmament proclaims the work of his hands” (Ps 19:2). All creation is the dwelling place of God’s Spirit. The true worshipers of God worship him in spirit and truth (cf. John 4:21–24). The strength of the Eucharist is the strength of the sign:

“The added value of the Church’s seven sacraments does not consist in their bringing more God, more Christ, more Holy Spirit, or in their effecting these in a secure manner, but in the power of expression that these signs bring about.” (Gottfried Bachl, quoted on p. 41)

For all the praise this book deserves, and for all the respect and esteem I have for Fr. Batlogg, this is the passage I find most challenging. From a Catholic perspective, I find it difficult not to see myself confronted here with a Protestantized understanding of the Eucharist. It could hardly have been stated more clearly.

God is everywhere. Yes. But even before we consider the sacramental presence in the Eucharist, experience and perception show us different degrees of density, as it were, in this presence. It is true: even our sins take place in God, “for in him we live and move and have our being” (Acts 17:28). To speak with Thomas Aquinas: creatures are more in God than God is in creatures. Hence even our wrongdoing takes place in God. Teresa of Ávila, incidentally, believed that if we grasped this, we would never sin. In another sense one can also say: where sin is, God is not; he is given no room there; he is excluded by the human person. God is present in an Auschwitz guard in a different way than in Maximilian Kolbe. His presence does not shine forth in Mother Teresa in the same way it does in a mass murderer. And this is not merely because the “sign” speaks so loudly, but because something qualitatively different is truly present here.

THE EUCHARISTIC AND PERSONAL PRESENCE OF GOD

Jesus is the sacrament par excellence because he does not merely visibly signify God’s presence in the world, but is that presence personally. Through him, God becomes personally present in a concrete place. Jesus Christ is not merely an exemplary human being who was especially close to God and therefore somehow brings God closer to us as a sign more effectively than other human beings. That would no longer be Christian faith.

What is breathtaking about the Incarnation is not so much the divinization of the human person (to take up an idea from Karl Adam)—the elevation of the human person to something he could never have achieved by his own powers—but God’s complete self-emptying and becoming fully human, which makes that divinization possible. There is a human being among us who is God himself. And everything he does as a human being reveals the heart of God to us, because the person, the subject, acting there as a human being is the eternal Son of the Father: God from God, Light from Light, consubstantial with the Father.

The bodily present figure of Jesus of Nazareth is the personal presence of the second Person of the Trinity. When we look into Jesus’ eyes, the unfathomable reality washes over us, wave after wave: we are looking into the eyes of God himself, who looks upon us with human eyes (as N. T. Wright writes). Because this is so, we can say: God wept. God suffered. God slept.

Is God present in the tree outside my front door? Yes. But to call that tree God would be blasphemous. To confess Jesus as God, on the other hand, is the very heart of what it means to be Christian at all. Is God’s presence in Jesus of Nazareth different in kind and quality from his presence in the tree? It would be difficult to continue calling oneself a Christian if one could not answer that question with a clear yes.

Jesus Christ is the origin and source of sacramentality. A Catholic understanding of the Eucharist can only be grasped by starting from him. I regret that the book does not really engage with this dimension. Above all, because without it the profound transformation of the human person through God’s action becomes unintelligible. Yet there is a rich tradition of believers who have understood throughout the centuries that what Jesus is by nature, we become through grace and participation. This is precisely what the sanctification of the human person consists in. It is not merely a matter of changing the outward façade, but of being “transformed in Christ”—to speak with Paul. We are transformed into his own image, from glory to glory (2 Cor 3:18).

SACRAMENTS AND HOLINESS

Or, to put it differently, the conspicuous absence of a sacramental worldview has consequences for what one understands by a saint in the first place. There is much debate about how Luther should be interpreted. The Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification, signed in 1999 by the Catholic Church and the Lutheran World Federation, showed that we are in fact closer on this matter than people had thought. The problem is that Luther has often been interpreted in the following way (put very simply): Jesus is, so to speak, the carpet thrown over the sinful human being, so that when God the Father looks at the sinner, he does not actually see the sinner but his Son. Yet the human being—that is, I—remains a sinner. This is a purely juridical understanding of justification.

I myself was adopted by my stepfather. I have a document stating that he is my legal father. I love and appreciate him very much. He has become like a father to me, and I regard him as such. But that does not make him my biological father. When Paul speaks of the “Spirit of adoption” (Rom 8:15), the German Einheitsübersetzung is not wrong to translate this as the “Spirit of sonship,” because God’s adoption truly brings about our being taken into the life of the Trinity and enables us to participate in it. In other words, unlike a piece of paper, God’s adoption really transforms us: “Through these [his divine power] he has bestowed on us his precious and very great promises, so that through them you may become participants in the divine nature …” (2 Pet 1:4). One of my favorite sentences in the entire Bible is 1 John 3:1: “See what love the Father has bestowed on us that we may be called the children of God. And so we are” (1 John 3:1; German Einheitsübersetzung 2016; Greek: kai esmen). We are not merely called children of God; we have truly become his children. “The love of God has been poured out into our hearts through the Holy Spirit that has been given to us” (Rom 5:5). And through the Spirit of adoption we cry, “Abba, Father!” (cf. Rom 8:15). This is about interior transformation—or, as the Eastern Church calls it, theosis: the divinization of the human person. “God became man so that man might become god” (cf. Athanasius, De incarnatione 54.3; paraphrased). Not that we all now become God, but that through grace we may participate in his very life: “… from glory to glory, by the Spirit of the Lord.”

Transformation is Possible

Yes, and on this point Fr. Batlogg is absolutely right: this is not about self-optimization. And yes, it is about a relationship with the Lord. Through him we will shine. That means something. Yes. We must not overburden people with false ideals. At the same time, we must not think too little of them. We cannot place the heart in a permanent state of suspicion: redemption is a reality. We are called to something higher—and effectively called to it through the power of God, genuinely enabled to attain that higher calling. Transformation is possible.

In 1980, John Paul II reminded priests in a homily in Fulda: Yes, we want to, must, and may confess our weakness to the Lord. At the same time, however, some seem …

“… today often to make this weakness the fundamental principle of everything else, virtually declaring it a human right. Christ, on the other hand, taught us that above all the human person has a right to his own greatness, a right to what actually surpasses him. For it is precisely here that a particular dignity becomes apparent; here the glorious power of grace is revealed: our true greatness is a gift from the power of the Holy Spirit. In Christ, the human person now has a claim to such greatness. And through the same Christ, the Church has a claim to the gift of this human person …” (John Paul II, Homily in Fulda, November 17, 1980, no. 8)

Fr. Batlogg repeatedly presents “heroic virtue” as a criterion for canonization as problematic. I agree that it is problematic if understood in a Pelagian sense: that is, if such “heroic virtue” could be achieved solely through one’s own efforts. This is precisely what Fr. Batlogg is targeting. But his criticism can also be misunderstood. Then there is a danger of implicitly rejecting the doctrine of virtue as such, radically applying the notion that “faith alone is sufficient,” and reviving a Gnostic tendency—as though salvation came more from knowledge than from love. This would deny the Holy Spirit’s power to transform our will, as well as our free cooperation.

Here too we need an integrated view of things, one that preserves a healthy tension between grace and free will. I am not sure the author succeeds in doing so. Paradoxically, rejecting a doctrine of virtue would lead back to clinging to, and multiplying, external rules (see, for example, The Four Cardinal Virtues by Josef Pieper). Why? Because we would not trust the interior of the human person, the heart, to receive through God’s grace the ability to order its behavior according to the demands of love without needing a multitude of external rules. Augustine’s “Dilige et quod vis fac” (“Love, and do what you will”; In epistulam Ioannis ad Parthos tractatus 7.8) would not seem trustworthy enough, or would seem too naïve. External supports would be required because the internal ones would not hold. But grace does precisely that: it strengthens the inner person.

Perhaps, then, it would be helpful to emphasize these aspects of encouragement even more. I am thinking of Ignatius’s “Magis.” Of Pope Francis’s “Make a mess” at World Youth Day in Rio, or “Get off the couch” at World Youth Day in Kraków. Of the “determined determination” that Teresa of Ávila commends to everyone who truly wishes to follow the path of holiness. Of John Paul II’s “Do not be satisfied with mediocrity.” Or of his reminder that asking a catechumen, “Do you wish to receive Baptism?” essentially means asking, “Do you want to become holy?” Christian life cannot be content with a mediocre existence and a minimalist ethic (cf. John Paul II, Novo millennio ineunte, no. 31).

I consider it important to emphasize this process of transformation so that we do not sell the human person short, because otherwise the human person cannot truly understand himself. John Paul II once expressed it this way: “The man who wishes to understand himself thoroughly—and not just in accordance with immediate, partial, often superficial, and even illusory standards and measures of his being—must with his unrest, uncertainty and even his weakness and sinfulness, with his life and death, draw near to Christ. He must, so to speak, enter into him with all his own self, he must ‘appropriate’ and assimilate the whole of the reality of the Incarnation and Redemption in order to find himself. If this profound process takes place within him, he then bears fruit not only of adoration of God but also of deep wonder at himself. How precious must man be in the eyes of the Creator, if he ‘gained so great a Redeemer’ … This deep amazement at man’s worth and dignity is called the Gospel, that is to say, the Good News.” (John Paul II, Redemptor hominis, no. 10)

Conclusion

With his book Being Holy 2.0, Fr. Batlogg wants to reclaim holiness for our time, to inspire us anew. But to do so he must identify the distorted images that have brought “holiness” into disrepute. The book helped me reflect again on where the dangers of an ego-driven spirituality of achievement and pride can lurk even in the pursuit of holiness. He shows how saints can be placed on pedestals so high that they seem unreachable and overwhelm us. He warns against instrumentalizing saints for one’s own purposes. He places the relationship with Jesus, and shining through him, at the forefront. The importance of this can scarcely be overstated. For all of that, I am grateful to the book.

My concern is the insufficient emphasis on the transformation of the inner person, on his cooperation with grace, and on the real possibility of his divinization—the essential reason for God’s Incarnation: God wants to enter into a covenant with the human person in order to divinize him, to let him participate in God’s own life. I therefore regret the omission of the sacramental dimension and, with it, the depth of Christian anthropology. This is true even though it is gently hinted at—for instance, when toward the end of the book the author holds out the hope that, through the experience of human goodness, even when the other person is not thinking of God, something might open up within that person and “whether this does not bestow an almost hidden access to the goodness by which we all live” (p. 172). I hope I will have the opportunity to explore these elements, as well as his understanding of the Eucharist, more deeply with him in another conversation.

The book is a courageous attempt to invite us to embark anew on the search for holiness and to burn inwardly so that we may shine (to take up a thought of Archbishop Josef Grünwidl). It reminds us: “Modern man listens more willingly to witnesses than to teachers, and if he does listen to teachers, it is because they are witnesses” (Paul VI, quoted by Fr. Batlogg on p. 169). It encourages a “mysticism of open eyes” (p. 170), one that notices the suffering of others and engages with it. And it awakens the desire to become people “through whom it becomes easier for others to believe in God” (p. 172).

Fr. Batlogg is a renowned and respected theologian in the German-speaking world and beyond. Yet this book does not set out to be an academic treatise on holiness. Fr. Batlogg wants precisely to make the subject accessible to a wider audience. At the same time, I find it significant that with this very book he helps call a theology perhaps too often preoccupied with peripheral issues back to its own center.

Fr. George Elsbett, LC